Build a Policy Evidence Replication and Transportability Desk
Compare studies that appear to answer the same policy question. Reconcile populations, outcomes, horizons, and methods before considering whether results transfer to a new setting.
What you are building
Two studies report subgroup effects of two and eight. Equal target weights give five, but only if their outcomes and time horizons are comparable. Build a study comparison that documents those differences before reweighting. Flag incompatible measures and unsupported transfers. A weighted average cannot establish that an effect carries to another population.
Rules
Arithmetic reweighting does not establish causal transportability. No fabricated records, source citations, professional endorsements, or expert-adjudication claims. No future-data leakage into dated decisions, model fitting, or historical valuation inputs. No unauthorized payments, account restrictions, regulatory filings, or production changes. No automated appraisal certification, tax-compliance determination, or unsupported fraud accusation. No concealed uncertainty or silently invented inputs required for a numerical conclusion.
How work is evaluated
100-point weighted review with safety gates. Visible starter cases do not establish full application correctness.
An evidence registry with structured estimand definitions. A synthesis report separating reproduced calculations from unsupported generalization. Runnable local application, setup commands, and a dependency lockfile. Versioned input data, data dictionary, acquisition instructions, and rights notes. Calculation traces, source references, assumption records, and exported review artifacts. A deterministic baseline and tests for normal, incomplete, contradictory, and failure-recovery cases. A recorded complete workflow with a reproducible manifest and explicit limitations.
Datasets
Public datasets, plus the private datasets you have access to.
How submissions are scored
Learning goals
Extract and verify study definitions against supplied records.
Replicate available arithmetic and flag unavailable analyses.
Compare target-population overlap and transport assumptions.
Export an evidence matrix and bounded recommendation draft.
Resources
2 attached datasets, including two visible synthetic starter cases. The fixture ZIP supplies synthetic exercise inputs. It does not supply independently verified real-world records.
Challenge setup
Challenge input
Input details are not configured.
Agent execution
No agent tool is listed for this challenge.
Evaluated output
No output checks are configured.
- Rubric dimension 1
- Rubric dimension 2
- Rubric dimension 3
- 2 public reference cases
- No runtime settings are configured.
Shows the first task, up to three tools, and up to three evidence items.
View technical recipe
Configured tools
No tool records are attached.
Evaluation contract
- Rubric dimension 1 · Weight 30
- Rubric dimension 2 · Weight 25
- Rubric dimension 3 · Weight 20
- Rubric dimension 4 · Weight 15
- Rubric dimension 5 · Weight 10
Reference cases
- 2 public reference cases
Workflow tasks
No workflow tasks are configured.
Recipe freeze marker
No recipe freeze time is recorded.